Shelby badged Mustangs are legendary American muscle cars.
Built from the peak of muscle in the 1960s all the way to today, these performance machines are some of the most recognizable cars on the planet. But… Not every Mustang deserves to wear that Shelby badge.
If you’re looking to collect classic cars, build an investment or enjoy driving your own classic Mustang reproduction built to the highest standard then learning everything about Shelby Mustangs is a MUST.
Let’s dive in…
What You’ll Learn About Shelby Mustangs:
- Shelby Mustang History
- What Makes Shelby Mustangs So Coveted
- How To Spot A Fake Shelby
- Why Classic Mustang Reproductions Are Rising In Popularity
- Are Shelby Replicas Worth It?
Shelby Mustang History
It starts with Carroll Shelby himself…
His goal? Take the wildly successful Mustang from Ford and make it a racer. Shelby American accomplished that mission by creating the GT350 in 1965. It was basically a road-going race car designed to take on the SCCA B-Production class. Lighter weight and tuned for performance, the GT350 won that championship for 3 consecutive years.
In 1967 Shelby increased the pony car’s performance with the legendary GT500. The more powerful model featured a 428 cubic-inch V8 under the hood. Only 2,048 were made that year creating instant scarcity.
Next up, the king of the Shelby badged Mustangs… The 1968 Shelby GT500 KR.
“KR” stands for King of the Road, and it was Shelby’s ultimate street-worthy horse at the time. Sharing the same 428 cubic-inch engine as the GT500, the KR featured a new high-performance version called the Cobra Jet. Ford officially rated the engine at 335 horsepower, but it was capable of over 400 horses. Like its predecessors, the Shelby GT500 KR was produced in limited numbers. Only 1,570 were sold that year.
This history of producing high-performance, limited production Mustangs quickly caught the eye of Ford and NASCAR.
When Ford needed a leader for its new high-performance division, they turned to Carroll Shelby to run Ford Performance.
As for Shelby American, the company lasted long after Shelby retired from daily operations. They produced a number of other incredible classic cars such as the famous Shelby Cobra. Shelby continues to build cars today although none quite have the fame of the classic Mustang reproductions they made in the 1960s.
Why Shelby Mustangs Are So Coveted
Simple.
They’re rare. They perform better than almost any other car from that era. And they’re incredibly cool.
Three words: That’s all you need to know.
Let’s break down why Shelby collectible cars have become so popular.
Original Shelby Mustangs aren’t mass produced by the dealership down the road. Back in the day, these muscle cars were completed by hand at Shelby American’s facility before being sent to the dealership. In fact, each Shelby Mustang has an individual Shelby serial number.
With that in mind, take a look at what makes these cars so desirable…
- LOW PRODUCTION VOLUMES – Original Shelby Mustangs were rare as soon as they rolled off the production line. For example, only 215 Shelby GT350s were produced in 1965.
- RACING LEGACY – These cars weren’t born to be sold at dealerships. Ford produced the Mustang in 1964 as a car anyone could afford. Shelby got his hands on a few and quickly dominated racetracks everywhere. In fact, the GT350R was a race-prepared version of the GT350 made exclusively for SCCA competitors.
- POP CULTURE ICONS – It speaks for itself. The GT500 owned the flick Gone in 60 Seconds as “Eleanor”. Carried by one of the coolest car chases in movie history, the Shelby Mustang is immortalized every time it rolls on screen.
- THEY’RE ONLY GETTING MORE EXPENSIVE – Classic cars were valued at $43 billion as of 2024. North America represents about 45% of worldwide demand. As younger generations look to invest in alternative markets, classic American muscle cars continue to grow in value.
Shelby Mustangs have been some of the most expensive muscle cars sold at auction over the last decade.
Collector cars that are verified to be in excellent condition are worth six figures. A Shelby Super Snake from 1967 sold in 2019 for $2.2 MILLION.
The demand to own a Shelby American classic will not die down.
How To Spot A Fake Shelby Mustang
This is where it gets shady.
Fake Shelby Mustangs are a huge problem. People have found shops that buy regular Ford Mustang fastbacks from the 1965 and 1966 model years, then slap Shelby parts on them and try to sell them as genuine Shelbys for a massive mark up.
And they’ve been doing it for years.
One investigation discovered shops that were literally taking VIN plates off of older cars and placing them on newly manufactured vehicles then selling them to unknowing buyers for hundreds of thousands of dollars.
So how do you make sure you don’t get taken advantage of?
VERIFICATION. Here’s what you should do.
- VIN NUMBER – Every Shelby Mustang has a VIN number like any other car plus an individual Shelby serial number. They should match up and can be verified by the Shelby American Automobile Club, commonly referred to as SAAC.
- SAAC – Speaking of SAAC, this is your new best friend. The Shelby registry allows members to verify any Shelby Mustang for authenticity at absolutely no cost.
- Marti Report – A Marti Report documents a vehicle’s original factory build information provided directly by Ford.
- Hire a marque expert – When it comes to investing in high-value vehicles, expert car inspections are always a good idea.
Trust your gut. If the price is too good to be true…
Someone is making money off of your lack of knowledge.
Classic Mustang Reproductions Are On The Rise
Why buy a car that could potentially be a clone when you can buy one that’s guaranteed to be authentic?
Original classic Mustang reproductions from manufacturers like RevologyCars come with full transparency. There’s no pretending these cars are something they’re not. You know exactly what you’re getting.
You also know how many of that model were produced and where that particular car is located in the production lineup.
Here’s how they differ…
| Reproduction Classic Cars | Clones |
|---|---|
| Transparent Sales Process. The builder proudly sells their car as a reproduction. | Implicit Clone Behavior. Trying to pass the car off as something it’s not. |
| Full Dealer Support. Because of how they build their cars, companies that build reproductions offer full dealer support. Warranties are available. | No Support. You’re on your own. Since clones are sold as real, original Shelby Mustangs there’s no recourse if something goes wrong. |
Need more reasons to buy a reproduction?
Original Shelby Mustangs aren’t built anymore so any you see for sale are at LEAST 60 years old. That means replacing body panels, upgrading fluids, and regular maintenance can get expensive. Plus, not many cars that old are still safe to drive on a daily basis according to new standards.
Restoration brings its own costs. And driving around a fragile vintage vehicle isn’t always fun.
Instead of restoring an original, why not buy new? Original-style Shelby Mustang reproductions offer modern drivetrains, upgraded suspension, better braking power, and use top quality materials.
Automotive authenticity is more important than ever.
Whether you’re buying an original Shelby Mustang or a reproduction, do your research. Verify everything you can and don’t let excitement about owning one of these legendary cars make you forget due diligence.
Final Thoughts On Shelby Mustangs
If you’re a car enthusiast, chances are Shelby badged Mustangs caught your attention.
Whether you want to start a collection, build long-term investments, or drive your own American muscle car… Shelby Mustangs are some of the best cars to own.
Here’s your quick Shelby Mustangs summary:
- Vintage Shelby Mustangs are rare.
- Unfortunately there are many counterfeit Shelby Mustangs for sale.
- Classic Mustang Reproductions provide an alternative to buying old/original cars.
- The collector market for these cars is strong and shows no signs of slowing down.
You can be a part of it. Just know the facts.